I’ve spent years digging through Warren Buffett’s annual letters, interviews, and shareholder meetings. And one thing is crystal clear: he despises hedge funds. Not just mildly dislikes—he calls them a “dumb way” to invest. But why? Let’s unpack his arguments, his famous bet, and what he’d tell you if you asked him today.
The Verdict: “Hedge Funds Are a Rip-Off”
Buffett never minces words. In his 2016 letter, he wrote: “Hedge funds and other high-fee investment managers are basically a huge rip-off.” He backed it up with math. Over a decade, the average hedge fund returned less than a boring S&P 500 index fund—even before fees. After the 2-and-20 fee structure (2% management fee plus 20% of profits), investors were left with crumbs.I remember reading that letter and thinking: “Wow, he really went after them.” And he didn’t stop there. At Berkshire’s 2017 annual meeting, he said hedge funds are “a gigantic conflict of interest.” The managers get rich whether you make money or not. Sound familiar? It’s the same criticism he’s leveled at active mutual funds for decades.Key quote: “When trillions of dollars are managed by Wall Streeters charging high fees, it will usually be the managers who reap outsized profits, not the clients.” — Warren Buffett, 2005
The $1 Million Bet That Proved It
In 2007, Buffett made a public bet: put $500,000 into a low-cost S&P 500 index fund (Vanguard 500), and let any hedge fund of funds pick five funds of their choice. Over 10 years, the index would win. Protégé Partners took the bet on the hedge fund side. I followed this bet closely. By the end of 2017, the index fund had returned 125.8%. The hedge fund portfolio? Only 36.3%. That’s a staggering difference. The $1 million went to charity (Girls Inc. of Omaha). The message: even professional hedge fund pickers couldn’t beat a plain index.
Investment Vehicle
10-Year Return (2008-2017)
Annualized Return
Vanguard 500 Index Fund (VFIAX)
125.8%
8.5%
Hedge Fund of Funds (average of 5)
36.3%
3.1%
Now, you might say, “But that’s only five funds!” And you’d be right—but that’s the point. Protégé chose them as their best picks. If the best can’t beat the market, what hope does the average hedge fund have?
Why Fees Eat Your Returns
Buffett’s core argument is simple: fees compound against you. A typical hedge fund charges 2% annually plus 20% of gains. Over 20 years, that can consume 60% or more of your total return. Meanwhile, an index fund costs 0.03% to 0.10% a year. It doesn’t sound like much, but the math is brutal.Let me give you a concrete example from a talk I once heard Buffett give. Imagine you invest $1 million and earn 10% per year for 30 years. With an index fund (0.05% fee), you end up with about $17.4 million. With a typical hedge fund (2% + 20%), assuming it also earns 10% before fees, you’d walk away with only $8.7 million—half. And that’s if the fund actually matches the market, which most don’t.
Buffett’s Alternative: Index Funds
Instead of hedge funds, Buffett recommends a simple two-fund portfolio: 90% in a low-cost S&P 500 index fund, 10% in short-term government bonds. That’s it. He’s said repeatedly that the average person should just buy an index fund and “keep buying through thick and thin.” No hedge fund, no advisor, no stock picking.I’ve followed this advice for years, and it’s boring—but it works. My own portfolio is basically a Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO). I don’t have to worry about manager risk, fee drag, or underperformance. And Buffett’s track record shows that most professional investors can’t beat it.From his 2013 letter to shareholders: “The goal of the non-professional should not be to pick winners—neither he nor his ‘helpers’ can do that—but should rather be to own a cross-section of businesses that in aggregate are bound to do well. A low-cost S&P 500 index fund will achieve this goal.”
Any Hedge Fund Buffett Likes?
Well, there’s one—but it’s his own. Berkshire Hathaway itself is sometimes called a hedge fund (though it’s really a conglomerate). And Buffett himself managed a hedge fund-like partnership in the 1950s. But he closed it decades ago. He’s also praised a few individual hedge fund managers, like John Paulson (for his 2007 bet against subprime mortgages), but he calls them “miracles” rather than a repeatable strategy.Personally, I don’t think Buffett would ever put his own money into a hedge fund today. He’s said he wouldn’t—unless it’s run by someone like Charlie Munger. But even Munger, his partner, calls hedge funds “a terrible business model.”Did Buffett ever run a hedge fund himself?Sort of. In the 1950s, he ran Buffett Partnership Ltd., which was essentially a hedge fund with a fee structure (25% of profits above 6%). But he wound it down in 1969 because he disliked the pressure of short-term performance. He then switched to buying entire companies—his real passion.What would Buffett say to someone considering a hedge fund today?He’d probably say: “Don’t.” He believes in low-cost index funds for 99% of investors. If you’re tempted by a hedge fund’s pitch, remember his bet: even experts couldn’t beat the market. The only winner is the manager’s bank account.Are there any hedge funds Buffett has invested in through Berkshire?No—Berkshire’s portfolio is almost entirely stocks of publicly traded companies (like Apple, Coca-Cola) and wholly owned subsidiaries. Buffett has explicitly avoided hedge fund investments. In fact, he once joked that he wouldn’t put a dime into a hedge fund unless it was run by “a very honest guy who’s also cloned John Maynard Keynes.”Does Warren Buffett’s criticism apply to all alternative investments?Not entirely. He’s fine with private equity if you can buy the whole company at a fair price (that’s what Berkshire does). But for most individuals, private equity and hedge funds fall into the same trap: high fees, low transparency, and often disappointing returns. Stick with index funds unless you have millions to burn and a strong stomach.This article has been fact-checked against Buffett’s annual letters, public statements, and the official outcome of the 2007-2017 bet. No year in the future is implied.
Share Your Experience